Science as Conversation, Part 1: “Is Pubmed Passé?”


Today at “lunch” I listened to a webcast presentation by a couple of my colleagues & peers here at the University of Michigan Health Sciences Libraries – Marisa Conte & Jean Song. They were presenting research data that is part of a project to develop improvements to the PubMed searching interface. The specific project under discussion today was MiSearch.
MiSearch: http://misearch.ncibi.org
MiSearch
I occasionally sent brief tweets to Twitter about the interesting data or concepts being presented. As a topic for another conversation, somehow I turned on LiveTweet by accident, so the tweets were captured as a session.
LiveTwitter: http://livetwitting.com/session/145
What was really interesting was the dialog that happened around the tweets. Specifically one comment in particular from Chris Seper.
Is PubMed Passé?

  • “Interesting. Is PubMed becoming passé? I just yanked the PubMed widget off Cleveland.com/medical. Replaces with ScienceRoll.”

Wow! You could have knocked me over with a feather right about then. As a medical librarian, and especially as someone heavily engaged with evidence-based healthcare and systematic reviews, Medline is a BIG part of my life! PubMed, Ovid, Silverplatter, GratefulMed, Dialog, Index Medicus, Index to Dental Literature … the list of tools I’ve used for searching the medical literature goes back through decades of my life, and the tools themselves (as well as the literature) go back around 150 years. I was “raised” (as a medical librarian) on Medline as the mother’s milk of authoritative medicine and healthcare.
I was immediately and urgently curious what it was about ScienceRoll search that inspired Chris to make this change. So I popped over to Chris’ page and checked it out. I noticed two big differences right away — (1) what information sources are being searched, and (2) how the results are being displayed.
SOURCES
Science Roll Example - Sources
RESULTS
Science Roll Example - Results
So what is so different? Well, when you use ScienceRoll’s search you do still get results from PubMed mixed in. That is also true of Google Scholar. ScienceRoll, though, is a bit like a blogroll — “who are your favorites?” ScienceRoll searches the crème de la crème of the medical web — World Health Organization, Centers for Disease Control, National Institutes of Health, Health On the Net, and many more. Then it gives you what it finds (a little, not too much, some consumer, some clinical) with more suggestions and ideas for refining your search. For a site targeting the general public I can definitely see why Chris felt this was a better choice than dumping John Q Public directly into the heart of the clinical dialog.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s